Book Group Questions

Mr S and I have been tearing up and down the UK this week on ‘Mr Rosenblum’s Great British Tour’. The youngest reader was Gemma, aged 11, and the oldest Rita, aged 96. Gemma told me her ambition to be a writer (and yes, I also knew I wanted to write when I was 11) while Rita told me about her husband who arrived from Berlin in 1937. She met him the very day after he disembarked at Harwich.

Since I’m not able to visit any more book groups (unless I’ve already confirmed a time and date with you), I’ve put together some book group questions. If you want to post another question/ start a discussion please feel free to do so in the comments below.

Book group questions:

‘Mr Rosenblum’s List’ explores the real split between the need to adopt the host country’s customs while not losing one’s own heritage, and an ambivalence about wanting children to blend in but turning them into strangers in the process. Do you think these tensions can ever be reconciled?

Names are significant indicators of heritage in the novel, and signify who belongs and who doesn’t. Do you think it is important to preserve what Jack calls the ‘chain’ of names?

Jack makes many mistakes in his attempts to access English culture. Do you think it is easier or harder for immigrants today to find a way in to society? Could a Helpful Information booklet such as the one Jack uses, ever be of any use? What items would you put on a modern list?

The novel mingles folklore and Jewish tradition. What do you think the woolly-pig symbolises?

Sadie bakes obsessively to remember her family. Does this help her overcome her grief, or does it paralyse her further? How do you feel Sadie changes when her baking becomes less of a lonely task and something that she shares with her daughter and the village women?

Jack’s obsession leads him to neglect his wife and their relationship is often strained and distant. Yet, when he nearly loses her, he regrets his behaviour and tries to make amends. Does Sadie forgive him? Can you?

Why does Curtis give Jack the recipe for ‘Jitterbug cider’? What makes Jack ‘a true Englishman’?

There is an undercurrent of anti-Semitism in the book, exemplified in the character of Sir William Waegbert. Why does Sir William despise Jack so much? Is it just because Jack is a Jew, or is it also that he is upwardly socially mobile and a threat to Sir William’s ‘old England’?

The landscape of Dorset becomes a conduit for Jack and Sadie. After years of growing apart, they connect once again through a mutual love of the countryside. It reminds Sadie of her idyllic childhood in Bavaria and she is able to recall happy memories of her family, but why do you think that Jack falls in love with the landscape? Why do the countryside rhythms comfort them both?

4 Responses to “Book Group Questions”

  1. Henriette says:

    Totally off topic – I can’t believe you have “my” milk jug! Where did you get it? I have the exact same, although mine is slightly broken 🙁 it used to be my grandmothers. I’ve never seen it anywhere else and I just love it.
    Greetings from Berlin!

  2. Natasha Solomons says:

    Ah-ha. That jug, Henriette, is not mine but Mr S’s. It’s one of his most prized possessions. His mother has one just the same (which she adores too) and for a special birthday, Mr S’s sister traced another for him. They were from the shop Habitat in the 1970s, I believe.

  3. […] Book Group Questions « Natasha Solomons Gemma told me her ambition to be a writer (and yes, I also knew I wanted to write when I was 11) while Rita told me about her husband who arrived from Berlin in 1937 Sadie bakes obsessively to remember her family. Does this help her overcome her grief, or does it paralyse her further? How do you feel Sadie changes when her baking becomes less of a lonely task and something that she shares with her daughter and the village women? […]

  4. Susan Holman says:

    Our book club has just finished Mr. Rosenblum’s List, we pondered the question ” what does the Woolly Pig symbolise ? What did others reply to that question ?

Leave a Reply